Great surprise when looking for a sweet bite in the area. Came in for a cookie and ended up with a couple (sweet & salty, and lemon poppyseed). I will be back while I am visiting the area. $2.75 each cookie but discounted price in bulk. Service was phenomenal as well. I recommend this place.
Note: They are actually located inside the shopping mall, in the basement, next to the elevators.
I’m a cookie connoisseur. I stay in touch with all the local bakers and try new places as I get the chance. I’m going to start rating places on the people, cookie taste/ texture and variety.
1- People: service was perfect. I was greeted, given recommendations and honest opinions on preference. 5/5 2- Taste/ texture: I have to admit, I like cookies with a variety of textures. For instance, their peanut butter (4.6/5 and highly recommended) has a soft interior, crunch on the perimeter with that signature sandy/ sugary coating. It tasted amazing and was close to perfect ( a little stronger on the peanut flavor and it’s flawless). The cookies and cream had great flavor but the texture was one note and denser than I prefer. The lemon poppyseed had all the textures going but was light on the lemon. I just crushed one so I’m not saying it’s not worth trying. I’d actually rank it #2 under the peanut butter. The birthday cake was good too, just eat it the day you get it. I’d pass on the snickerdoodle, m&m and the toffee one. They simply lacked flavor and were off texturally. 2.5/5 3- Variety: I’m starting to sense a theme around Seattle. These shops seem to be copying Menüs of competitors and putting their spin on it. That to me is risky unless you feel you have a superior cookie. I won’t name names but the peanut butter is the only one that was different and the one I’d say go get 6 of them. Get a lemon too. Nothing out of the box or really unique. 2/5