I won't ruin your 5 star rating because you deserve it for being in the middle of nowhere with super high quality food. I'm not sure if I'm just spoiled with good food because of where I live or if my expectations were way too high due to the 100% 5 star reviews but here is my take:
Brisket sandwich was very good. The nunya sauce is beyond. I forgot to ask if I could buy some to go. We do have a bbq joint at home where the brisket can't be beat though. So incredibly smokey.
The potato salad was ALMOST perfect. I'd suggest experimenting with some of the following: dill, salt, pepper, seasoning salt, garlic and onion powder, paprika. Or if you have that in there it needs way more. Potatoes need quite a bit of salt to taste good. Also more mayo - it was a touch dry.
The beans were GREAT! Never had baked beans like that.
I'd suggest wind barriers for wimpy tourists like ourselves. The wind made the meal far less enjoyable than it had to be.
Service was great! Very friendly and accommodating. We got the knuckle sammich to share and they thought ahead, asking if they could split it. Just a nice little touch.
It's expensive but so is everything up here. For the sandwich, a milkshake and a coffee it was around $40. We're cheap so we shared and it was plenty of food with the sides. We weren't stuffed to the gills.
I am way too spoiled for coffee where I'm from so the mocha was ok. A little too sweet for my taste. Should have asked for an extra shot or two
Thanks for the fun experience!